I fear I’ve officially entered my English muffin era… and I’m not leaving anytime soon.
I told myself I wanted to make a new homemade English muffin + butter combo every single week this spring, and this one might be my favorite yet. Like I am actually so obsessed.
These are soft, fluffy, perfectly chewy, loaded with melty cheddar, and have just the right amount of jalapeño kick. It’s giving bakery, it’s giving brunch, it’s giving “why would I ever buy store-bought again?”
And don’t even get me started on the honey butter. Fresh, homemade butter whipped with honey and a little flaky salt?? I could eat it with a spoon.
Also… quick side note… Jay made me a breakfast sandwich with these and I was like wow yes I am in love with you. White cheddar, egg, bacon, spicy mayo… unreal.
So yeah. You need these in your life immediately.

Ingredient Breakdown:
For the Jalapeño Cheddar English Muffins
- Whole Milk (1¼ cups, warmed to 100–110°F)
Warm milk activates the yeast and helps create a soft, tender dough. The temperature is key here, too hot will kill the yeast and too cold won’t activate it. Whole milk adds richness and flavor compared to lower fat options. It also contributes to that soft, fluffy interior. - Active Dry Yeast (2 teaspoons)
This is what gives the muffins their rise and airy texture. Letting it bloom in warm milk ensures it’s active and ready to go. You’ll know it’s working when it gets foamy. This step is key for proper dough development. - Unsalted Butter (3 tablespoons, melted)
Butter adds richness and flavor to the dough. It also helps create a soft crumb and slightly tender texture. Using melted butter allows it to incorporate easily. It’s a small amount but makes a big difference. - Honey (2 tablespoons)
Honey adds a subtle sweetness that balances the spice from the jalapeños. It also helps feed the yeast and contributes to browning. The flavor pairs perfectly with cheddar and the final honey butter topping. It ties everything together. - Egg (1 large)
Egg adds structure, richness, and helps bind the dough. It also contributes to the soft texture of the muffins. Make sure it’s room temperature so it mixes evenly. This helps create a more cohesive dough. - Bread Flour (3¼–3½ cups)
Bread flour gives these muffins their chewy, structured texture. It has a higher protein content than all-purpose flour, which helps with gluten development. Start with the lower amount and add more as needed. The dough should be soft but not sticky. - Salt (½ teaspoon)
Salt enhances all the flavors and balances the sweetness. It’s especially important with cheese and bread. Without it, everything would taste flat. Always include it. - Jalapeños (2, seeded and finely diced)
Jalapeños bring a subtle heat and fresh flavor. Removing the seeds keeps it from being too spicy while still giving that kick. Finely dicing ensures even distribution. It’s the perfect savory contrast. - Cheddar Cheese (4 oz, shredded)
Cheddar adds richness, saltiness, and melty goodness. It pairs perfectly with the jalapeños and gives that cheesy pull. Shred your own for best melting. It makes these feel extra indulgent. - Cornmeal (for dusting)
Cornmeal gives that classic English muffin exterior texture. It prevents sticking and adds a slight crunch. It’s what gives you that bakery-style finish. Don’t skip it.
For the Honey Butter
- Heavy Cream (1 cup)
This is how you make homemade butter, which is honestly so fun and so worth it. Whipping separates the fat from the buttermilk. The result is fresh, creamy butter that tastes unreal. It’s a game changer. - Honey (2 tablespoons)
Honey sweetens the butter and pairs perfectly with the savory muffins. It adds a smooth, natural sweetness. You can adjust based on preference. It makes the butter feel extra special. - Flaky Sea Salt (optional)
This adds the perfect finishing touch. A little salt enhances the sweetness and balances everything. It gives that sweet-salty combo that’s so addictive. Highly recommend.
Substitutions & Modifications:
- Use all-purpose flour instead of bread flour (slightly less chewy)
- Swap cheddar for pepper jack for extra spice
- Leave jalapeños in with seeds for more heat
- Add cooked bacon bits for extra flavor
- Use store-bought butter if short on time

Why You’ll Love this Recipe:
- Better than store-bought in every way
- Soft, fluffy interior with that classic English muffin texture
- Perfect balance of cheesy + spicy
- Made with simple, real ingredients
- Versatile for breakfast sandwiches or just butter + honey
- That homemade honey butter is next level
Equipment Needed:
- Mixing Bowl – For combining and mixing the dough
- Stand Mixer or Hands – Needed to knead the dough until smooth and elastic
- Baking Sheet – For resting and proofing the cut muffins
- Parchment Paper – Prevents sticking and keeps cleanup easy
- Biscuit Cutter – Helps create uniform muffin shapes
- Cast Iron Skillet – Gives that classic golden English muffin crust
- Spatula – For flipping muffins while cooking

Easy Homemade Jalapeño Cheddar English Muffins (+ Honey Butter)
Ingredients
For the English Muffins
- 1¼ cups whole milk warmed to 100–110°F
- 2 teaspoons active dry yeast
- 3 tablespoons unsalted butter melted
- 2 tablespoons honey
- 1 large egg
- 3¼ –3½ cups bread flour
- ½ teaspoon salt
- 2 jalapeños seeded and finely diced
- 4 oz cheddar cheese shredded
- Cornmeal for dusting
For the Honey Butter
- 1 cup heavy cream
- 2 tablespoons honey
- Flaky sea salt optional
Instructions
Make the Dough
- Warm milk to 100–110°F. Add yeast and let sit for 5–10 minutes until foamy.
- Add melted butter, honey, and egg. Mix until combined.
- Add bread flour and salt. Mix until a dough forms.
- Fold in diced jalapeños and shredded cheddar cheese.
- Knead dough for 8–10 minutes until smooth and elastic.
First Rise
- Place dough in a greased bowl, cover, and let rise for 60–90 minutes or until doubled in size.
Shape
- Roll dough to about ¾–1 inch thickness.
- Cut into 12–15 rounds using a biscuit cutter.
- Lightly dust with cornmeal and place on a parchment-lined baking sheet.
Second Rise
- Cover and let rise for 30 minutes.
Cook
- Heat a skillet (preferably cast iron) over low heat.
- Cook muffins for about 8 minutes per side until golden brown.
- Optional: Transfer to a 300°F oven for 5 minutes to ensure they are fully cooked through.
Make Honey Butter
- Whip heavy cream for about 10 minutes until butter separates from buttermilk.
- Strain and reserve buttermilk.
- Beat butter with honey until light and fluffy. Add flaky salt if desired.
Notes
- Make sure milk is not too hot or it will kill the yeast
- Dough should be soft but not overly sticky
- Cook low and slow to fully cook the center
- Always split with a fork, not a knife, for that classic texture
- Shred your own cheese for best melt and flavor
Nutrition
Storage & Reheat Instructions:
- Store in an airtight container for up to 4 days
- Refrigerate for up to 1 week
- Freeze for up to 2 months
- Toast or warm in skillet before serving
Tips & Tricks
- Make sure milk isn’t too hot or you’ll kill the yeast
- Dough should be soft but not sticky
- Cook low and slow so the inside cooks through
- Always use a fork to split, not a knife (trust me)
- Shred your own cheese for best melting
Frequently Asked Questions
Why didn’t my dough rise?
Your yeast may be inactive or your milk was too hot.
Can I make these ahead of time?
Yes! Store and reheat or freeze for later.
Do I have to use bread flour?
No, but it gives the best texture.
Can I make them less spicy?
Yes, just reduce or omit the jalapeños.
Do you LOVE From Scratch Recipes?! Check Out MORE of my Favs:
Homemade Limoncello (The Easy, From-Scratch Italian Lemon Liqueur You’ll Want to Sip All Year Long)
Homemade Salted Caramel Latte (Iced or Hot!) with From-Scratch Syrup
Brown Butter Maple Cinnamon English Muffins
I’m not kidding when I say… once you make these, you’re going to question every store-bought English muffin you’ve ever had.
They’re soft, flavorful, slightly spicy, cheesy, and paired with that honey butter?? It’s just next level.
If you make these, I need to see!! Tag me, comment, rate the recipe… all the things 🫶
And follow along because we are fully in our homemade bread era this spring and I have so many more coming 🤍







Leave a Reply